PySide2: Difference between revisions

From Qt Wiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(Redirected page to Qt for Python)
 
(97 intermediate revisions by 7 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
[[Category:Pythonic]]
#REDIRECT [[Qt_for_Python]]
== Pyside for Qt 5.x ==
 
The Pyside 2 project aims to provide a complete port of PySide to Qt 5.x. The development started on [https://github.com/PySide GitHub] in May 2015. The project managed to port Pyside to Qt 5.3, 5.4 & 5.5. During April 2016 The Qt Company decided to properly support the port (see [https://groups.google.com/forum/#!topic/pyside-dev/pqwzngAGLWE details] ).
 
This wiki page tracks the progress of PySide for Qt 5.x development and provides further information concerning the effort.
 
=== Tools ===
The following tools are used to develop PySide:
* Bug tracker: https://bugreports.qt.io/browse/PYSIDE
* CodeReview: https://codereview.qt-project.org
* Git repo: ssh://codereview.qt-project.org/pyside/pyside-setup (dev branch is Pyside2)
 
=== Getting started ===
 
[[PySide2_GettingStarted|Getting started with PySide2]]
 
=== Missing Qt bindings ===
[[PySide2_Missing_Bindings|Missing Qt bindings]]
 
=== Backlog ===
 
The list below represents some short term targets and long term ideas for Pyside2 development. There is no guarantee that this will happen as written down. It is meant as a short reminder and idea collection for future development. In the long term this list is likely to move to https://bugreports.qt.io/browse/PYSIDE.
 
# First time with Pyside (Document how to get started on this wiki)
# Testing Infrastructure
## What has been done so far?
## Qt CI support ([https://bugreports.qt.io/browse/PYSIDE-431 PYSIDE-431])
### make test
### cmake based build system (all repos)
### pip installable Pyside
#### CI has to setup virtual Python environment
#### Use pip to install/build Pyside (release bundling)
 
# Future changes to PySide
## Gaps (modules & API)
### Identify the extent of the gaps by porting existing examples from Qt4 to Qt5 (done)
### Plugin system (in what form or shape do we need it is uncertain - some failing tests exist already)
### Prepare a summary of gaps for other modules
## Fundamental Architecture changes
### Shiboken
#### Clang support ([https://bugreports.qt.io/browse/PYSIDE-323 PYSIDE-323])
### QtQML support ([https://bugreports.qt.io/browse/PYSIDE-355 PYSIDE-355])
## MyPy (type annotation - fully typed Python API)
## General Python features and their adoption in PySide (e.g. Async I/O)
## Creator and tooling
### Fix QtC debugger to understand Python/C++ mixed internals
## Documentation generation
## Deployment of apps
## Debugging support
 
 
=== Pyside Development Progress Notes ===
 
The most current view of the progress can be found in Jira:
 
# [https://bugreports.qt.io/secure/IssueNavigator.jspa?mode=hide&requestId=17825 Unresolved issues]
# [https://bugreports.qt.io/secure/IssueNavigator.jspa?mode=hide&requestId=18025 All issues (including resolved)]
 
The second link is useful to monitor the progress of the backlog. The best way to achieve this is to sort the list by the "Updated" column.
Larger backlog/feature items are filed as "User Stories" in Jira.
 
==== 04. May 2017 ====
- Coin
  - libclang 4.0 provisioning available (code reviews ongoing -> enabler for Pyside and qdoc testing)
  - 5.6 coin issues resolved
  - macOS related CI/cmake failures were resolved
  - some CI sync issues among pyside submodules (always submodules HEAD is tested)
  => may have to change once we come closer to the final release ->
  => fine as long as we are in heavy development mode
  - discussion around Ubuntu and OpenSuse configurations
  - minimal cmake requirements not met on all distros
    - 5.6 only be build using RedHat 6.6
    - 5.9 builds have updated Linux distros -> may be able to obtain a new cmake version without hacking the standard toolchain
- QtMultimedia and QRaster* API bindings further completed
- added tests and examples for the above bindings/APIs
- PYSIDE-510 (required for simplified and more generic testing of bindings)
- PYSIDE-504 work is ongoing
- PYSIDE-507 -> avoid hardcoded includes when certain Qt modules are not available
- brief discussion whether to merge the shiboken and pyside repo
  -> advantages from a CI perspective and reduces pyside setup complexity
 
==== 26. April 2017 ====
- Coin
  - provision for 5.9+ branches -> we would like to use libclang 4.0
  - test still not yet executed due to branch mismatch which pulls in dev branches
- missing bindings in QtCore/QtGui/QtMultimedia - work in progress
- clang support done (except for a Mac issue)
  - Pyside clang version required Qt 5.7 or later
- [https://bugreports.qt.io/browse/PYSIDE-500 PYSIDE-500] done
- work on PYSIDE-500, 502, 504, 497 will continue
- qdoc work started trying to recover whatever documentation is left from Pyside 1.x
 
==== 20. April 2017 ====
- Fix for [https://bugreports.qt.io/browse/PYSIDE-331 PYSIDE-331] broke the Windows build; under investigation
- Refactoring, fixed build warnings
- Looked at debug builds on Windows
 
==== 13. April 2017 ====
- discussion around merge policies between 5.9 and 5.6 branch
- Linux debug library issues fixed
- PYSIDE-488 fixed via workaround
- fixed a unit tests
- worked on qdoc/html generation in Pyside (failed so far - waiting for qdoc maintainer feedback)
- PYSIDE-331 patches merged -> more bugs found in the meantime
 
==== 6. April 2017 ====
- 5.6 branch created
- 5.9 branch to be created as well (easier setup for Qt 5.9 testing in Coin)
- Coin
    - not passing build platforms have been disabled
    - otherwise COIN passing on 5.6 (except for 2 failing test) -> soon to be enforced
    - license checker passing in dev
- clang changes merged to dev branch (after reviews)
  - clang provisioning on Coin still missing
- for now shiboken is not a generic C++ bindings generator (targeting Qt use cases only)
- TODO: enabling the generation of documentation from repos
- fixed mixed usage of debug and release build (no debug builds for windows)
- [PYSIDE-331] work continuing - fixed, tests are missing
 
==== 30. March 2017 ====
- Coin
    - some platforms passing and will be enabled by default
    - MinGW, some OSX and cross compile targets remain out
- will branch pyside dev branches to 5.6, new dev becomes clang branch
    - regular merges from 5.6 -> dev will start happening
    - Pyside 5.6 branch will continue to work against Qt 5.6
- need reviews for [https://bugreports.qt.io/browse/PYSIDE-323 PYSIDE-323] to merge clang changes
    - Qt 5.10, 5.9 (on main desktop plawtforms working)
    - for now the Pyside dev development will be based on Qt 5.9 (to be bumped up later on)
- [PYSIDE-331] - in progress
- [PYSIDE-156] -
 
==== 23. March 2017 ====
- Coin
  - progressing
- More tests fixed
- wip/clang branch created, will receive Clang parser port with instructions
- Refactoring of shiboken, replaced QtXml classes by QXmlStreamReader allowing for stricter error checking
 
==== 16. March 2017 ====
- Coin
  - the fixes are still integrating or are under review (no further progress until this is done)
- clang parser replacement [https://bugreports.qt.io/browse/PYSIDE-323 PYSIDE-323]
  - most test failures related to clang are fixed
  - tests ran pretty much through on Qt 5.9 (Windows and Linux - Mac not yet verified)
  - code cleanups in shiboken
  - will create feature branch on all pyside repos to get the clang patch series under CI control
  - merges from regular pyside branches into clang branch will commence
  - readme required that explains how clang is to be built (if not provided by platform)
- [PYSIDE-331] - in progress
 
==== 09. March 2017 ====
- Coin
  - lots of changes in Gerrit for Pyside and coin
  - the outcome has to be check once everything merged
  - upcoming clang dependencies in shiboken introduces new requirements for Coin
  - clang changes to be dealt with after pyside branching
- clang
  - first complete bindings generation with Qt 5.6 and Qt 5.9
  - some failing unit tests which have to be looked at individually
  - actual merge depends on pyside branching which in turn depends on recent Coin changes
- smart pointer support
  - patches generally done, gerrit review ongoing
  - rather large patch
- created list of missing bindings in Pyside ([https://wiki.qt.io/PySide2_Missing_Bindings Missing Bindings])
  - mostly class level view, global functions at al not covered
- Jira cleanup
  - PYSIDE-464, PYSIDE-217, Pyside-224 fixed
  - most bugs reviewed now and valid ~100 bugs were identified
 
==== 02. March 2017 ====
- Coin
  - Coin runs tests on Windows and OSX (some failures in the test - to be investigated)
  - Windows provisioning somewhat blocked due to CI issues
  - no progress on Linux
  - OSX 10.8 ran tests with expected results
  - OSX 10.9 has issues due to Pyside not supporting namespace builds of Qt
- clang
  - preprocessor has remaining issue
      -> with clang compiler but gcc seems OK
      -> Qt Core wrapper close to compiling (QHash issues remaining)
- Smart pointer work continues
  - some uses cases work, other use cases might remain
- [https://bugreports.qt.io/browse/PYSIDE-364 PYSIDE-364] was fixed (patch pending)
- General error review on bugreports.qt.io
  - 50% done (prioritized bugs are handled/checked bugs - "done" bugs)
- ran address and leak sanitizer over Pyside which resulted in some worrying cases (need to be addressed going forward)
 
==== 22. February 2017 ====
- [https://bugreports.qt.io/browse/PYSIDE-462 PYSIDE-462] Improved solution approved
- [https://bugreports.qt.io/browse/PYSIDE-205 PYSIDE-205] Hard-to-detect memory leak plugged
  - slow memory leak found in shiboken with thousands of false positives
  - used differential analysis of valgrind output
- Clang: Fixed Preprocessor handling (set defines, include paths), got minimal binding tests to pass, now adapting MetaBuilder and PySide to what Clang finds when parsing Qt. Good news: Very little need to set Q_DOC or other magic defines
- Coin: Slow progress, currently struggling with provisioning
- extensive bug triaging ongoing in Pyside Jira project
 
==== 16. February 2017 ====
- Coin (no update - other priorities in release/CI team)
- Clang (progressing on pre-processor work)
- PYSIDE-315 closed
- PYSIDE-462 more review needed
- Shared pointer API very slowly progressing (lots of different fixes needed)
- QMimeDataBase support added
- QUrlQuery support blocked on QDOC defines in Qt sources (shiboken sets the wrong define)
- chasing memory leaks (PSYIDE-205)
- extensive bug triaging ongoing in Pyside Jira project
  - confirming and testing the reported bugs (70 of 200 processed)
  - some smaller bugs were fixed in the process
- quite a few bugs were discovered this week while working on the above items, e.g.:
  - deployment of pyside applications partly broken due to hard-coded install paths in Qt libs
  - Qt events are swallowed when Pyside error/exception occurs
-
 
==== 9. February 2017 ====
- Clang progressed
  - pure C++ tests for API extractions are passing (C++ parsing based on clang)
  - even works with cmake
  - old C++ preprocessor still to be replaced
  - working through old preprocessor and checking what magic it did and how clang might be able to replace it
- PYSIDE-315 & PYSIDE-462 fixes pending for review
- COIN
  - continue progress an getting more platforms to pass (unblocking one step at a time)
  - Windows (32bit) and mac are building, Win 64bit still not building
  - OSX and Windows are stopping in the test runner phase
  - missing cmake update still on Linux (provisioning update required)
 
==== 26 January 2017 ====
- PYSIDE-315
  - principle fix merged but some minor improvements still pending
- Pyside-462
  - essentially a feature request as C++ default parameters are not yet supported by Pyside
  - discussion ongoing how to address the problem
- COIN
  - 10.11, 10.9 & 10.8 build passes
  - 10.10 still failing during build
  - Progress on Windows and running into new problems further down the path
  - Redhat failed to general brokenness of the platform in CI
  - Ubuntu no further progress
- clang parser work progressing
  - completeness of work is currently measured by passing unit tests
  - there is a long way to go
  - see [https://bugreports.qt.io/browse/PYSIDE-323 PYSIDE-323] and associated patches for progress monitoring
- Fixed regression which prevented Pyside to compile with Qt 5.5.1
- shared pointer support
- no update on 2nd February 2017 (next week)
 
==== 19 January 2017 ====
- PYSIDE-315
  - a possible fix is pending, some minor performance improvements are still possible
  - caused by different signal/slot ordering in Qt4 and Qt 5
- COIN
  - issues on 10.8 and 10.9 platforms should pass now
  - 10.11 & 10.10 still have issues
  - Windows timeout problem fix in COIN (but no COIN update until 5.8.0 released)
  - Linux builds are failing
    - Ubuntu 14.04 fails due to cmake issue
    - Redhat 6.6 & OpenSuse 13.01 deferred
  - current COIN freeze for 5.8.0 release affecting patching of COIN for Pyside
  - next steps in priority -> run tests on 10.8/10.9 and get Linux running
- PYSIDE-79 regression fixed as well (some interaction between PYSIDE-315 & PYSIDE-79)
- PYSIDE-462 to be looked at next
- clang parser work progressing
 
==== 12 January 2017 ====
- PYSIDE-315
  - sorting of slots/signal connection changed on Qt side and Pyside side has not caught up
  - had similar connection issues on the QML side, need to investigate whether there is a connection
- PYSIDE-79
  - caused a regressions (not yet investigated)
- fixed OpenGL types not being recognized on MacOS (partly fixed)
- API's with shared/smart pointers in Qt don't work
  - has potential long term effects and investigation has started into the reasons
- Refactoring shiboken in preparation for clang
- COIN currently runs tests with namespaced Qt
  - short term fix to exclude namespaced Qt builds with Pyside (broken on MacOS 10.9)
  - other failures: missing libraries on MacOS (10.11), missing provisioning on Windows, cmake issues on 10.10
  - unknown state on Linux (current Redhat too old)
- Prioritization after status round:
  - PYSIDE-315 to be investigated based on recent signal/slot patches for QML
  - Smart pointer issues reduced in priority to provide space for PYSIDE-315 & PYSIDE-79 regression
- verify that COIN runs testrunner (not just building Pyside)
  -> not yet verified since we are still failing builds in COIN
 
==== 5 January 2017 ====
- COIN update
  - COIN changes merged (no further patches pending)
  - need to run an integration test
  - issues related to different build platforms still to be expected
- Continue with clang
  - backtracking a bit (reusing some node API's during parsing but otherwise use clang to populate the tree)
- test blacklisting reviewed (some removed - mostly signal related ones, one new regression)
- regressions in QtQuick were worked around (caused by recent Qt Quick changes)
- issues with macos framework style includes in Qt
- PYSIDE-315 debugging ongoing, very hard to track down
    - was it a regression from a previous Pyside release (e.g. Qt 5.4?!?
- hard-copied Qt 5.4 based headers still in existence
  - updated needed but would shut Qt 5.4 users out
 
==== 22 December 2016 ====
- lots of discussions around the COIN patches
  - source archive setup being under review
  - Qt 5.6 provisioning patches merged
  - CI uses Python 2.7 at this stage
- clang C++ parsing continues
- fix of some Pyside unit tests (now have a clean slate again)
- finished QtQuick port
- some overflow problems have been fixed in shiboken
 
==== 15 December 2016 ====
- COIN changes pending for testing infrastructure
    -> https://codereview.qt-project.org/177136 (Pyside change)
    -> https://codereview.qt-project.org/176968 (Coin change)
    -> https://codereview.qt-project.org/179662 (Provisioning changes)
    -> https://codereview.qt-project.org/179663 (Provisioning changes)
- waiting for COIN development team to review/accept the pending changes
- no update in PYSIDE-315 (under investigation)
- Flushed out a couple of shiboken, QML, qml example bugs
- Some bugs related to parser delayed until clang parser task done (https://bugreports.qt.io/browse/PYSIDE-322)
- most basic shiboken API extractor test to pass (global enumeration test)
- some trouble with int size data types
    -> Python 2 & 3 are different and the relevant C++ data types are yet again different from platform to platform
 
==== 8 December 2016 ====
- COIN patches pending approval
  - Windows provisioning reviewed
  - Linux, Pyside, COIN itself
- Clang changes progressing, comparing AST tree from old parser and clang
- PYSIDE-79 done
- PYSIDE-315 under investigation
- QtQuick patches taking shape (some template magic and function pointer
  features in Qt cannot be parsed by shiboken)
 
==== 1 December 2016 ====
- COIN
- PYSIDE-79 there seems to be a final work around (https://codereview.qt-project.org/#/c/176374/)
    - fixing a few tests in the process
- clang update
  - dumping AST, identifying the required info
  - work in progress...
- problems with global static QObjects on the Qt side calling back into Python during app exit
  - may require some changes on the Qt side
 
==== 24 November 2016 ====
- automatic COIN triggering for submodules work in progress
  - several discussions on this topic this week
- Clang investigation (what library to use)
- fixing bugs on Qt side for Pyside
- Qt QML support almost done, work will continue with Qt Quick
- PYSIDE-79 work story continues
  - reference counting not quite accurate but point of deallocation of ref count not identifiable
 
==== 17 November 2016 ====
- Pyside team suffering from sickness -> not much progress this week
- Pyside-79 fix had a lot of negative side effects (breaking existing tests)
  - internal object reference counting is the predominant issue at hand
  - continue to work on the bug (no resolution yet as delayed due to sickness)
- COIN some progress but still open discussions on branching policy required
 
==== 11 November 2016 ====
- PYSIDE-79 being fixed
- PYSIDE-315 to be addressed
- Shiboken and Clang
  - familiarizing with clang and its parser's inner working
  - added experimental qmake project definition for shiboken (makes work in Qt Creator easier)
- Qt QML on Pyside work progressing
- work on COIN did not progress due to conflicting priorities inside COIN development
 
==== 3 November 2016 ====
- working through the QML stack esnuring all required API's are exported (https://codereview.qt-project.org/#/c/175682/)
- small build system patches
- PYSIDE-79 work progressing
- OpenGL support fixed (PYSIDE-314)
- COIN issues
    - repo interdepencies not working yet, suggestion under discussion and to be implemented
    - most license checks have been fixed
    - Qt 5.6 based Pyside to skip check
    - after branching for C++11 work the dev branch should work from license check perspective
    - eventually the entire CI needs to run through (more hidden problems could be hidden)
- Started working on C++11 compliant parser for shiboken
    - libclang will be used
    - first target is to replace the AST tree implementation
    - requires clang setup in the CI
 
==== 27 October 2016 ====
- Work on WebKit/WebEngine support
- Further work on [https://bugreports.qt.io/browse/PYSIDE-431 COIN] support
- Planning meeting
- Workshop for C++11 support in Pyside ([https://bugreports.qt.io/browse/PYSIDE-323 PYSIDE-323])
 
==== 20 October 2016 ====
- [https://bugreports.qt.io/browse/PYSIDE-355 Qt Quick support] submitted
- [https://bugreports.qt.io/browse/PYSIDE-314 QtOpenGL support] submitted
- Further work on [https://bugreports.qt.io/browse/PYSIDE-431 COIN] support, license headers
==== 13 October 2016 ====
- Qt CI update
  - Coin changes have merged but integration not yet working
  - Qt CI enables on Pyside side merged
  => COIN integration fails with license issues
  => requires review of license conditions for all files, some files are not even relicensable
  => skipping license check for now, most likely to be done later again but requires changes to license check script
  - more issues of interworking between QtCI and Pyside expected (won't be visible until license problems resolved)
  Open issue: does a change in Pyside repo trigger a rebuild of everything?
- Qt QML support progressing and first patches merged
  - serious bugs have been fixed, more complex QML examples are now working
 
==== 29 September 2016 ====
- Coin integration close but not merged
- Bugfixing in particular on the shiboken parser side
- QML/Python binding and tests fixed -> general check all day-to-day aspects of QML are working
- QML examples porting
    -> still some failing tests
    -> Check all QML/Quick class are exported
 
==== 22 September 2016 ====
- Refactored Shiboken, udnerstanding build sequences
- black list for unit tests defined and tested
- fixing of tests
- QML example fixing continued (QML bindings not working)
- Pyside side for COIN done (pending integration checks)
- COIN integration still wip due to long test and retest cycles
- pyside and shiboken repo to be relicensed similar to other Qt products
=> this should address any issues regarding the status of generated code too
==== 16 September 2016 ====
- Pyside side for CI testing ready for testing
- status of COIN side to be determined. Code exists need help from CI team to confirm status.
- build system infrastructure improvements in pyside setup
- Qt logging now working
- and more
- Update on bug handling
  - PYSIDE-88 continuing
  - PYSIDE-349 (Multimedia ported)
  - PYSIDE-344 fix pending on codereview
  - make debug builds of Pyside work (OSX works, Linux has work in progress patch, Windows side awaiting contribution)
- QML support work in progress
  - examples are slowly ported with aim to identify bugs
 
==== 25 August 2016 ====
- Properly implementing QML experience in Pyside
- Unit test fixing
- automated CI testing for Pyside
  - working locally but still failures occurring on various other test machines
 
==== 4 August 2016 ====
- Additional Pyside examples under review
- Fixed warnings coming from Shiboken
 
==== 21 July 2016 ====
 
- main Pyside 2 example port done
- additional examples to fill gaps are being ported (as per prio list)
- CI patches running, but still gaps (should be done by next week)
- about 86% of auto test working (failing count of test 80+ auto test)
- [[pyside-Teststatus|Project Test Status]]
 
==== 14 July 2016 ====
 
- Pyside 2 examples ported
- OpenGL & SVG not working
- QtQuick 2 is in strange situation (QtQml depends on QtQuick)
- Python 3 realed Unicode handling not working with Qt
- QMessageBox hangs
- no documentation for any example
- lots of warnings when building wrapper
- results: https://paste.kde.org/pgje2toyh/mlbqic
- COIN setup for pyside https://codereview.qt-project.org/#/c/158336/
- Qt 5.7 still blocked due to missing C++11 support in shiboken
    - food for ideas: https://steveire.wordpress.com/
 
 
==== 7 July 2016 ====
 
- automated CI testing
- patches for Pyside and Qt CI side required
- Testing somewhat more complicated due to closed nature of Qt CI
- script to port examples to Qt 5 -> https://bugreports.qt.io/issues/?jql=labels%20%3D%20exampleport5
- all examples to remain BSD licensed

Latest revision as of 11:09, 18 April 2018

Redirect to:

Retrieved from "https://wiki.qt.io/index.php?title=PySide2&oldid=33245"